Fixing a Frankenstein Faith: Ten Distortions of Scripture and How to Correct Them

In yellow lamplight I stayed up late the other night talking with my wife, burdened about another church gone to seed in Texas.

The sect looks so much like my former church in Maine, a Bible cult which maximized suffering and overlooked grace. The platitudes and sermons coming from the group sound so familiar they almost seem scripted. It’s as if every unhealthy church reads from the same dysfunctional playbook—merely making minor changes in regard to set, costume, and character.

I felt discouraged, until I remembered that there is still one Hero who can swoop down to save the day. No matter how much a Christian group twists scripture—no matter how fearful or controlled the people become—Jesus can still rescue them.

The Situation: Mutually Exclusive Exclusiveness

The group I have in mind is representative of a thousand other groups, each of whom believes it alone possesses the truth. While giving lip service to the idea that there are other genuine believers scattered around the world, in practice they believe that everyone else is a false Christian. They believe that they alone have interpreted Scripture correctly, and that they alone will be saved in the latter days. This helps them to rationalize their cruel behavior toward the “unelect,” that is, anyone with the audacity to stand against the claims of their leader.

competing_christian_sectsThe hubris of these sects is astounding. Each group believes that they have discovered true Christianity as God intended; that through much dint of effort they have returned to the fold of Christ; and that the rest of the professing Church is a synagogue of Satan.

Oh really? A synagogue of Satan? How ironic. Because that’s exactly what the other exclusive groups think about your exclusive group.

The irreconcilable paradox is that if these isolated groups discovered each other—not the “liberal” mainline churches, mind you, or the “3000-mile-wide-but-one-inch-deep” evangelical Church, but the tiny, tenacious, tunnel-vision groups popping up all over the place who believe that they alone are the elect—they would fight like cats and dogs in a theological version of King of the Mountain.

“We have the truth!” one group would shout. “No, no! We do!” a second would cry. “Come to our little church and be saved!” a third would chime in. They would bloody each other—these elite Christian sects—like pugilists in the ring, well aware that their exclusiveness makes them mutually exclusive. After all, if you alone have the Truth, then that other group from Missouri or Maine or Michigan must not.

At the end of the day each sect would slink back to its rarified community in complete isolation, damning the world—humbly, of course, and with much praising of God—and decrying the arrogant errors of the other groups.

The Problem: Heterodoxy Leads to Heteropraxy

Despite the geographical distribution of sects, cults, and spiritually abusive churches, most of these groups function in very similar ways. They have twisted the meaning of scripture and have left the straight path of doctrine (orthodoxy). Instead, their distorted belief (heterodoxy) leads to distorted practice (heteropraxy).

twisting_scriptures_equals_frankenstein_faithIn other words, they behave badly because they believe wrongly.

Rather than outright heresy such as denying the deity of Christ, their errors are often subtle distortions of scripture. They can trot out a hundred verses to support their position, sure, but each verse is wrenched out of context like a Christmas bulb pulled from a tree. Thrown on the floor and trampled into broken crystals by the clumsy feet of false interpretation, these verses become a wounding snare to the people who profess them.

In this upcoming series I want to focus on ten distortions of Scripture which my own cult practiced—and which I see cropping up time and again in other spiritually abusive ministries.

Notice that I call these “distortions” rather than lies. They are lies, of course, but they are lies which start with a truth and then twist it ever-so-slightly out of plumb to create a Frankenstein monstrosity.

We want to fix this Frankenstein faith.

Distortion #1: Love Thy Neighbor But Hate Thy Parent

Distortion #2: “Because I’m Your Pastor/Elder/Spiritual Leader, that’s Why!”

Distortion #3: Vestigial Organs in the Body? Natural Family vs. Spiritual Family

Distortion #4: Brother’s Keeper: Surveillance in Spiritually Abusive Churches

Distortion #5: “It Says in Deuteronomy…”: Misuse of the Old Testament

Distortion #6: God or Mammon: Logical Fallacy of the Excluded Middle

Distortion #7: I Committed Adultery Watching the Smurfs: James 4:4 Unpacked

Distortion #8: You Shall Be Holy Unto Me (So Ditch the Budweiser)

Distortion #9: “We Alone are the ‘Remnant,’ all 75 of Us!”

Distortion #10: Fun in the Shun? Confessions of an Excommunicator

Stay tuned for these upcoming posts…

8 comments on “Fixing a Frankenstein Faith: Ten Distortions of Scripture and How to Correct Them

  1. I am so glad I came across this site. I have lost a grown son and family to a group just like you describe. We were cut off a year ago. There are about 40 adults in this group. I am writing from Canada. Every article you write could be speaking of them.

  2. Hopeful Mother, check out faith.boardhost.com. It’s about a specific group and event, but intends to be a general resource, applicable to groups with similar practices.
    If nothing else, it’s validation that other families are in the same boat.

    [i]”The group I have in mind is representative of a thousand other groups, each of whom believes it alone possesses the truth.
    Despite the geographical distribution of sects, cults, and spiritually abusive churches, most of these groups function in very similar ways.”[/i]

  3. I don’t like what it says about _us_ as a nation, on a continent with some of the wealthiest people in the world; one of the highest standards of living on the planet and unlimited educational and social opportunities.
    Not to mention unqualified expectations of religion and a church on every corner.
    That we would have this much emotional/spiritual deficiency, angst and turmoil, that people feel so empty and unfulfilled, seeking out anything that makes them feel better.

    • Indeed. Arthur J. Deikman, M.D., has written a book entitled “The Wrong Way Home: Uncovering the Patterns of Cult Behavior in American Society.” He says that the same psychological needs which propel some people into cults are also evident in American Society at large. It is a fascinating read. I think you’d enjoy it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: